This eyeliner goes on smoothly, and can be sharpened to a fine point without the entire tip falling out of the pencil. Very easy to use and apply. Stays on for hours and I have a very physical job. I never need to reapply. Easy to smudge or blend, equally easy to draw a thin line. Comes off easily with make up remover or just soap and water, yet holds up against sweat and humidity just fine. I would compare the quality of this eyeliner to that of Lancome at 1/6th the price! You cannot go wrong with this purchase. Black/Brown shade is true to its name with the color applied in between that of dark brown and rich black. Read more
I don't know why this brand can no longer be found in stores. It's by far the best eyeliner pencil I've found - not too hard, not too soft. It goes on smoothly, is not sticky, sharpens nicely, the charcoal color is perfect, and the price is very reasonable. It also lasts right down to the bottom - no nasty surprises when the filler runs out while there are still three inches of pencil left. Read more
I have been searching for Prestige eye pencils for some time - had them from a while ago from local drug store but haven't found them. Found them here on Amazon but only 2 colors. I love green, blue, black and brown and would buy them if I found them. They were much more expensive here but in the long run worth it! Read more
I usually have always used an eyeliner called Barry M Khol, in black. I've used that down to the NIB! I had been on the lookout for a new replacement because i can't seem to find Barry M in the US. So i recently found a review on here that pushed me to try this one out. In looking for an eyeliner, i like ones that don't feel like im dragging a pencil across my eyes. That i'm able to draw a line across my lids and then smudge with my finger. I want it to stay all day and not end up looking like a panda! Well, this one seems to do the trick. I will usually pull my eyelid to the side and i will draw a line (like i'm using liquid liner)across my eyelids close to the lashes and i usually do the cat eye flick at the side. I will then do the other side, so they match and then i will smudge to give a smokey look. This went on and it was creamy but not slippery. It was a bit sharp when i first used it, but it was because it was sharpened to a point and had not been used before. It's a bit harder than my old khol, but it's not llike some i've used. It does not seem to be a cheap quality. I will definitely buy this one again. I've used it 4 times now and i also use it on my lower , inner lash line. One of the reviewers had said that it was MAC quality. I would have to agree and then some. I know people seem to love mac, and i will say that their eye shadows are the best (pigment wise), but i have never liked their eye liners. This is a great find and i will buy from no on! Read more
This is fantastic eyeliner. Soft and smooth to apply, does not hurt my eyelid putting it on. Its easy to blend but doesn't smear too easily (a bit moves and i will tidy it up after a shower since it's not waterproof - but nothing major..no clown eyes). it does not irritate my eyes (i wear contacts so i have to be aware of anything getting in my eyes. Sometimes i notice my eyes feel 'itchy' at the end of a night when i'm wearing eyeliner, prompting me to remove it all. I don't get that with this eyeliner, though i do try to remember to remove before bed anyway. I can wipe it off with a q-tip, no makeup remover required. I ordered brown, which seems quite a dark brown color. I'm perfectly happy with it, doesn't appear too dark on my eyes. Others may prefer to look a different shade if you want a lighter brown. Read more
Awesome basic, creamy, pencil liner! This eyeliner is super creamy and doesn't feel "waxy" at all like other cheap eyeliners, so it doesn't pull on your eyelids at all. It glides on very smooth. I usually wear it on my upper waterline without too much smudging. I will also layer it with a liquid eyeliner on top, and the results are fabulous. Could easily be smoked out for a quick and easy smokey eye on the go, since it's so creamy! I have very sensitive, watery eyes (even flash photos make them go watery), but this doesn't cause any irritation. But because of my super watery eyes, I think my eyeliner is just naturally prone to more smudging than most women. If you don't have a watery/super sensitive eyes, it shouldn't be a problem at all. Wish it came in gold or some more metallic colors. I would buy it for sure! Read more
I've never before had reason to rave about an eyeliner pencil. It arrived with the tip broken and no sharpener but I was able to get a decent point using a sharpener from another manufacturer. This pencil is just the right firmness (firmer than most, but still can be blended) and just the right color (darker than most browns, but not a black). I have sensitive skin and have tolerated this with no problems. It has stayed on all day even through a sweaty workout. And then it comes off when I want it to come off (I wipe with Cetaphil cleanser on a cotton pad and then a gentle wash and moisturizer). Excellent all around! Read more
This eyeliner is a nice dark black and goes on easily... maybe a little too easily. I have yet to wear this out in public because whenever I put it on, it immediately smudges on my upper eyelids when I look up. I do admittedly have oily eyelids so eye primer might help... but I've had other black eyeliner pencils that I could wear fine without any primer and have no smudging for several hours AND they were much cheaper than this. I will keep trying it with primer, but I wish I had saved my money and gotten a cheapo drugstore eyeliner that works for me. Read more
