Sabrena—January 6, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I have been buying this brand for years! It’s perfect for that winged cat eye look and waterline. I first started buying this brand when a friend of mine told me it was the only brand they were told to use for the dance team at our high school. That is because it is waterproof, sweat proof and will not run! Also the little jar lasts a long time! Affordable and stays on all day Read more
Melissa—May 20, 2025✓ Verified purchase
When this arrived it was dried out. I tried moistening it back up, but nothing worked to my standards. It was so dry using the enclosed brush didn't even put a dent in it. The only way to get any out was using a toothpick, which "worked" but then there isn't a way to actually apply it, as it being dry won't easily go onto eyelids. The eyelids being so delicate I don't want tug and pull at them to even try to get this on. I tested it on my hand and as I had thought, no real color, practically turned to dust when I tried it. Safe to say this had no glide or ease of application. On the hunt for a good gel eyeliner since the one I use to love is discontinued. The hunt continues. I've noticed lately that Rimmel quality has gone down hill Read more
Pamela—April 28, 2024✓ Verified purchase
I do love eyeliner gel BUT the problem is it was hard to put on my eyes because it was almost dry and now I can't use it hardly when I got it. I don't think I will be ordering this kind again. Read more
Eric Robertson—September 27, 2024✓ Verified purchase
This is as it is described, however it does smudge. It's a gorgeous black. You have to have a very thin brush so it does not look cakey goes on easily. It is waterproof and you can only wear it 24 hours. After that it starts to come off. Easy to take off but it does smudge easily wood purchase again Read more
Amari Bailey—September 16, 2025✓ Verified purchase
The media could not be loaded. It did not come hard like the others. I do live in a hot state and it’s still kind of hot out here so I do believe the weather played a part in the gel being soft but it is a pretty good product, quality is thick and smooth. It is water proof so you would need to apply light pressure to remove. Not a huge make up fanatic but I am trying to get back to it. Also it is a good price too. I recommend if it is hard and if it’s still warm where you are at sit in the window or direct/indirect sunlight where you know it’s going to be warm. Read more
Leigh Kepford—February 12, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Does not go on smoothly and it smears. Read more
Rena proctor—January 21, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Dark and long lasting Read more
Mia Clay—June 29, 2022✓ Verified purchase
I've used this gel eyeliner for years, but lately I haven't been able to find it in the stores. This is my favorite eyeliner so I was ecstatic to find it on Amazon. The gel is usually so smooth it's effortless to put on. The product I received was not how it should be. The packages were wrapped in bubble wrap and were already open, whether from heat or it being old. Immediately when I opened it and dipped the brush in I realized it had a hard, dryer texture than usual. The stuff was so stiff and sticky that I could barely get it on my eyelids. It kept sticking to my eyelashes and wouldn't spread smoothly. This is usually how it starts to get after it's been used for a while and you're getting down to the bottom of the jar. I hoped that since I bought 2, at least one would be good...but unfortunately both jars of eyeliner are the same consistency. It took me forever to get my eyes lined and almost immediately it started cracking and flaking. It's really not usable at all Read more