Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil Dark Brown Matte Waterline Eye Liner Pencils Slim Angled Tip Long Lasting Smudge Proof

I am really impressed with the eyeliner. The color is as pictured, dark and rich (see the attached photo showing it next to a black eyeliner, I got the green). The tip is so fine that it was really, really easy to get a tight lined look, which is what I prefer to do. It’s not super soft, but also not difficult to apply to get smooth color. I was able to put it onto my waterline comfortably, and it lasted well there. It also lasted all day without smudging on my eyelid, but still came off comfortably with micellar water. I’ve also included a photo where I’d been washing off the swatches on my hand — that photo was taken after about 45 seconds of rubbing with soap and warm water, and you can see that the black eyeliner was starting to come off, but this eyeliner was not; the black eyeliner in that photo is a high-end name brand that is also waterproof, and that I absolutely love, which I think demonstrates how well this competes even with products that are double or triple price. It’s a great value and I recommend it. Read more

I ordered this retractable waterproof gel liner in “dark brown” because I wanted a softer alternative to black. PROS The retractable design is really convenient, especially if you twist out too much product by accident. The slim angled tip makes it easy to get precise lines, and it helped a lot when trying to create a wing. Once it sets, it truly is waterproof and smudge proof. I wore it all day and it stayed in place without transferring. It also works well for the waterline and under-eye area if you want a softer look. CONS The “dark brown” shade is not actually dark brown. It’s much lighter than expected and didn’t give me the deep brown look I was going for. It also didn’t apply evenly in one pass. I had to do a few layers to build up consistent color, especially along the lash line. Overall, I like the design and staying power, but I wish the shade was darker and the color payoff was more even. Read more