Monumental Controversies cover

Author

Harriet F. Senie

More by this author

Monumental Controversies

Mount Rushmore, Four Presidents, and the Quest for National Unity

by Harriet F. Senie

PreviewPDFGoogle Books

About this book

In recent years the United States has witnessed major controversies surrounding past American presidents, monuments, and sites. Consider Mount Rushmore, which features the heads of the nation’s most revered presidents—George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln, and Theodore Roosevelt. Is Rushmore a proud national achievement or a symbol of the U.S. theft and desecration of the Lakota Sioux’s sacred land? Is it fair to denigrate George Washington for having owned slaves and Thomas Jefferson for having had a relationship with Sally Hemings, an enslaved woman, to the point of dismissing these men’s accomplishments? Should we retroactively hold Abraham Lincoln accountable for having signed off on the largest single-day mass execution in U.S. history, of thirty-eight Dakota men? How do we reckon with Theodore Roosevelt’s legacy? He was criticized for his imperialist policies but praised for his prolabor antitrust and conservation programs. These charged issues and many others have been plaguing our nation and prompting the removal of Confederate statues and flags amid racial unrest, a national pandemic, and political strife. Noted art historian Harriet F. Senie tackles these pivotal subjects and more in Monumental Controversies . Senie places partisan politics aside as she investigates subjects that have not been adequately covered in classrooms or literature and require substantial reconciliation in order for Americans to come to terms with their history. She shines a spotlight on the complicated facts surrounding these figures, monuments, and sites, enabling us to revisit the flaws of our Founding Fathers and their checkered legacies while still recognizing their enormous importance and influence on the United States of America. Monumental Controversies presents strategies to create an inclusive narrative that honors the varied stakeholders in a democracy—a vital step toward healing the divisiveness that now appears to be a dominant feature of American discourse. As the public and press reconsider the viability of the American experiment in democracy, Senie offers a thoughtful reflection on the complex lives and legacies of the four presidents memorialized on Mount Rushmore. All four presidents faced some of the most contentious times in our history and yet they championed unity, made possible by acknowledging and accepting opposing opinions as a basic premise of democracy. Historians, curators, government officials, academics, and students at all levels will be riveted by this authoritative work.

Publisher

U of Nebraska Press

Published

2023-04

Pages

256

Language

EN

Architecture / Buildings / Landmarks & MonumentsHistory / United States / GeneralHistory / Social History

Preview & Source

Google Books provider

Preview bookView on Google BooksFind similar booksExplore category

Preview

Monumental Controversies cover

This book is available for preview through Google Books.

More by Harriet F. Senie

Monumental Controversies cover
Architecture2023-04

Monumental Controversies

Mount Rushmore, Four Presidents, and the Quest for National Unity

Harriet F. Senie

In recent years the United States has witnessed major controversies surrounding past American presidents, monuments, and sites. Consider Mount Rushmore, which features the heads of the nation's most revered presidents--George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln, and Theodore Roosevelt. Is Rushmore a proud national achievement or a symbol of the U.S. theft and desecration of the Lakota Sioux's sacred land? Is it fair to denigrate George Washington for having owned slaves and Thomas Jefferson for having had a relationship with Sally Hemings, an enslaved woman, to the point of dismissing these men's accomplishments? Should we retroactively hold Abraham Lincoln accountable for having signed off on the largest single-day mass execution in U.S. history, of thirty-eight Dakota men? How do we reckon with Theodore Roosevelt's legacy? He was criticized for his imperialist policies but praised for his prolabor antitrust and conservation programs. These charged issues and many others have been plaguing our nation and prompting the removal of Confederate statues and flags amid racial unrest, a national pandemic, and political strife. Noted art historian Harriet F. Senie tackles these pivotal subjects and more in Monumental Controversies. Senie places partisan politics aside as she investigates subjects that have not been adequately covered in classrooms or literature and require substantial reconciliation in order for Americans to come to terms with their history. She shines a spotlight on the complicated facts surrounding these figures, monuments, and sites, enabling us to revisit the flaws of our Founding Fathers and their checkered legacies while still recognizing their enormous importance and influence on the United States of America. Monumental Controversies presents strategies to create an inclusive narrative that honors the varied stakeholders in a democracy--a vital step toward healing the divisiveness that now appears to be a dominant feature of American discourse. As the public and press reconsider the viability of the American experiment in democracy, Senie offers a thoughtful reflection on the complex lives and legacies of the four presidents memorialized on Mount Rushmore. All four presidents faced some of the most contentious times in our history and yet they championed unity, made possible by acknowledging and accepting opposing opinions as a basic premise of democracy. Historians, curators, government officials, academics, and students at all levels will be riveted by this authoritative work.

Memorials to Shattered Myths cover
Art2015-12-01

Memorials to Shattered Myths

Vietnam to 9/11

Harriet F. Senie

Memorials to Shattered Myths: Vietnam to 9/11 traces the evolution and consequences of a new hybrid paradigm, which grants a heroic status to victims of national tragedies, and by extension to their families, thereby creating a class of privileged participants in the permanent memorial process. Harriet F. Senie suggests that instead the victims' families be able to determine the nature of an interim memorial, one that addresses their needs in the critical time between the murder of their loved ones and the completion of the permanent memorial. She also observes that the memorials discussed herein are inadvertently based on strategies of diversion and denial that direct our attention away from actual events, and reframe tragedy as secular or religious triumph. In doing so, they camouflage history, and seen as an aggregate, they define a nation of victims, exactly the concept they and their accompanying celebratory narratives were apparently created to obscure.

Memorials Now cover
Art2025-01-13

Memorials Now

Cher Krause Knight, Harriet F. Senie

A comprehensive guide to addressing the present-day challenges of commemorating the past As debates over historical monuments and their meanings unfold, Memorials Now offers a critical exploration of how communities can navigate the complex terrain of commemorative practices. From controversial statues to emerging forms of public memory, the topics covered in this timely volume provide insights into historical challenges while also encouraging a more inclusive and just memorial landscape for the future. Authors Cher Krause Knight and Harriet F. Senie explore evolving narratives of heroes and victims, ethical challenges of memorial design, strategies for promoting inclusivity, and possibilities for alternative forms of commemoration. Memorials Now analyzes case studies from around the world in which communities are rethinking their memorials and creating innovative memorialization projects that reflect shifting cultural values. Memorials Now is ideal for students and educators in art history, architecture, urban planning, and cultural studies, as well as professionals in fields such as public art, city planning, museum curation, and civic engagement.

Museums and Public Art? cover
Book2021-10

Museums and Public Art?

Cher Krause Knight, Harriet F. Senie

While many museums have ignored public art as a distinct arena of art production and display, others have â " either grudgingly or enthusiastically â " embraced it. Some institutions have partnered with public art agencies to expand the scope of special exhibitions; other museums have attempted to establish in-house public art programs. This is the first book to contextualize the collaborations between museums and public art through a range of essays marked by their coherence of topical focus, written by leading and emerging scholars and artists. Organized into three sections it represents a major contribution to the field of art history in general, and to those of public art and museum studies in particular. It includes essays by art historians, critics, curators, arts administrators and artists, all of whom help to finally codify the largely unwritten history of how museums and public art have and continue to intersect. Key questions are both addressed and offered as topics for further discussion: Who originates such public art initiatives, funds them, and most importantly, establishes the philosophy behind them? Is the efficacy of these initiatives evaluated in the same way as other museum exhibitions and programs? Can public art ever be a â oepermanentâ feature in any museum? And finally, are the museum and public art ultimately at odds, or able to mutually benefit one another?

Similar books

Monumental Controversies cover
Architecture2023-04

Monumental Controversies

Mount Rushmore, Four Presidents, and the Quest for National Unity

Harriet F. Senie

In recent years the United States has witnessed major controversies surrounding past American presidents, monuments, and sites. Consider Mount Rushmore, which features the heads of the nation's most revered presidents--George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln, and Theodore Roosevelt. Is Rushmore a proud national achievement or a symbol of the U.S. theft and desecration of the Lakota Sioux's sacred land? Is it fair to denigrate George Washington for having owned slaves and Thomas Jefferson for having had a relationship with Sally Hemings, an enslaved woman, to the point of dismissing these men's accomplishments? Should we retroactively hold Abraham Lincoln accountable for having signed off on the largest single-day mass execution in U.S. history, of thirty-eight Dakota men? How do we reckon with Theodore Roosevelt's legacy? He was criticized for his imperialist policies but praised for his prolabor antitrust and conservation programs. These charged issues and many others have been plaguing our nation and prompting the removal of Confederate statues and flags amid racial unrest, a national pandemic, and political strife. Noted art historian Harriet F. Senie tackles these pivotal subjects and more in Monumental Controversies. Senie places partisan politics aside as she investigates subjects that have not been adequately covered in classrooms or literature and require substantial reconciliation in order for Americans to come to terms with their history. She shines a spotlight on the complicated facts surrounding these figures, monuments, and sites, enabling us to revisit the flaws of our Founding Fathers and their checkered legacies while still recognizing their enormous importance and influence on the United States of America. Monumental Controversies presents strategies to create an inclusive narrative that honors the varied stakeholders in a democracy--a vital step toward healing the divisiveness that now appears to be a dominant feature of American discourse. As the public and press reconsider the viability of the American experiment in democracy, Senie offers a thoughtful reflection on the complex lives and legacies of the four presidents memorialized on Mount Rushmore. All four presidents faced some of the most contentious times in our history and yet they championed unity, made possible by acknowledging and accepting opposing opinions as a basic premise of democracy. Historians, curators, government officials, academics, and students at all levels will be riveted by this authoritative work.

Mount Rushmore cover
Book2014-12-12

Mount Rushmore

The History and Legacy of America's Most Unique Monument

Charles River Charles River Editors

*Includes pictures *Includes accounts of the work by supervisors and workers *Includes a bibliography for further reading *Includes a table of contents "America loves the representation of its heroes to be not just larger than life, but stupendously, awesomely bigger than anything else. If blue whales built statues to each other they'd be smaller than these." - Simon Hoggart In the 1920s, plans were made to carve the figures of America's greatest presidents into Mount Rushmore, the tallest spot in the Black Hills of the Dakotas, and by 1939, the faces of George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln, and Theodore Roosevelt had been carved into the rock. With that, one of America's greatest national monuments was born. The four men were certainly worthy of being immortalized in granite, and Mount Rushmore poignantly symbolizes the legacies and legends of the four presidents (which often overshadow the actual men themselves). Every American is taught a pristine narrative of the life and legacy of George Washington and can easily recite the highlights and myths of Washington's life. Thomas Jefferson was instrumental in authoring the Declaration of Independence, laying out the ideological groundwork of the notion of states' rights, leading one of the first political parties, and overseeing the expansion of the United States during his presidency. Schoolchildren can recite the life story of Lincoln, the "Westerner" who educated himself and became a self made man, rising from lawyer to leader of the new Republican Party before becoming the 16th President of the United States and saving the Union. And at the turn of the 20th century, Theodore Roosevelt came to be recognized as the quintessential American, remembered for being a president, explorer, hunter, author, soldier, president, and safari adventurer, all of which combine into one unique reputation. Given the sheer size and scope of the project, it's no surprise that Mount Rushmore was a gargantuan undertaking in every conceivable way. Originally envisioned as a monument that would help spur tourism to South Dakota, it took hundreds of workers nearly 15 years to laboriously dynamite and carve the likenesses of the four presidents' faces into the side of Mount Rushmore about 60 feet up. As if the final product wasn't ambitious enough, the supervisors originally envisioned carving all the way down to each president's waist, and including a commemoration of achievements like the Declaration of Independence alongside the figures. Amazingly, the entire project cost less than $1 million and there were no fatalities. Mount Rushmore: The History and Legacy of America's Most Unique Monument chronicles the construction of the national monument that commemorates some of America's most famous individuals. Along with pictures of important people, places, and events, you will learn about Mount Rushmore like never before, in no time at all.

Memorials Now cover
Art2025-01-13

Memorials Now

Cher Krause Knight, Harriet F. Senie

A comprehensive guide to addressing the present-day challenges of commemorating the past As debates over historical monuments and their meanings unfold, Memorials Now offers a critical exploration of how communities can navigate the complex terrain of commemorative practices. From controversial statues to emerging forms of public memory, the topics covered in this timely volume provide insights into historical challenges while also encouraging a more inclusive and just memorial landscape for the future. Authors Cher Krause Knight and Harriet F. Senie explore evolving narratives of heroes and victims, ethical challenges of memorial design, strategies for promoting inclusivity, and possibilities for alternative forms of commemoration. Memorials Now analyzes case studies from around the world in which communities are rethinking their memorials and creating innovative memorialization projects that reflect shifting cultural values. Memorials Now is ideal for students and educators in art history, architecture, urban planning, and cultural studies, as well as professionals in fields such as public art, city planning, museum curation, and civic engagement.

Mount Rushmore National Memorial cover
Historic sites1941

Mount Rushmore National Memorial

A Monument Commemorating the Conception, Preservation, and Growth of the Great American Republic

Mount Rushmore National Memorial Commission

Description unavailable for this volume in the current provider response.

Mount Rushmore National Memorial cover
History2021-11-05

Mount Rushmore National Memorial

A monument commemorating the conception, preservation, and growth of the great American republic

Mount Rushmore National Memorial Society of the Black Hills

Mount Rushmore National Memorial, written by the Mount Rushmore National Memorial Society of the Black Hills, is a comprehensive exploration of one of America's most iconic landmarks. The book delves into the historical significance of Mount Rushmore, its artistic value, and the cultural impact it has had on society. The narrative is presented in a scholarly tone, filled with detailed descriptions and analysis of the monument's intricacies, making it a valuable resource for those interested in American history and art. The book not only covers the creation of Mount Rushmore but also explores the controversies and debates surrounding its existence, offering a well-rounded perspective on the subject. The literary style is engaging yet informative, making it accessible to a wide range of readers. Mount Rushmore National Memorial serves as a testament to the lasting legacy of this monumental achievement and its enduring impact on American culture. Recommended for history buffs, art enthusiasts, and anyone fascinated by the stories behind famous landmarks.

Mount Rushmore cover
History2025-02-19

Mount Rushmore

Amelia Khatri, AI

""Mount Rushmore"" explores the multifaceted story behind the iconic sculpture carved into the Black Hills, examining its construction, the figures it portrays, and the controversies it embodies. The book delves into how this colossal monument, intended to draw tourism to South Dakota, became a complex symbol of American achievement intertwined with the displacement of the Lakota Sioux, who consider the Black Hills sacred land. Understanding the monument requires acknowledging both its artistic and architectural grandeur and the fraught history of westward expansion. The book examines the selection of Gutzon Borglum, the sculptor, and the innovative engineering techniques employed to carve the presidential faces, including the contributions of local miners. It dedicates significant attention to the four presidents depicted—Washington, Jefferson, Lincoln, and Roosevelt—analyzing the rationale behind their inclusion and the conflicting interpretations of their legacies. Drawing upon archival documents, personal papers, and oral histories, the book progresses from the monument's conception to its ongoing debates, offering a comprehensive account that connects American history, Native American studies, and art history. This exploration provides a nuanced perspective, acknowledging Mount Rushmore as a symbol of American democracy while critically examining its historical context and ethical considerations. By addressing ongoing debates and alternative proposals, the book encourages readers to engage critically with the complex legacy of Mount Rushmore and its place in American society, enriching the understanding of historical memory and the challenges of preserving cultural heritage.

Book details

Publisher: U of Nebraska Press

Published: 2023-04

Pages: 256

Language: EN

Categories: Architecture / Buildings / Landmarks & Monuments, History / United States / General, History / Social History

Preview: Sample available

PDF: Available

Ventari Books links to external provider metadata and access states and does not rehost copyrighted text.

We use optional analytics and advertising cookies to understand how visitors use Ventari, measure ads, and improve the experience. You can accept all optional cookies, allow analytics only, or decline them. See our Cookie Policy.