Barred by Congress cover

Author

Robert M. Lichtman

More by this author

Barred by Congress

How a Mormon, a Socialist, and an African American Elected by the People Were Excluded from Office

by Robert M. Lichtman

PreviewPDFGoogle Books

About this book

In Barred by Congress: How a Mormon, a Socialist, and an African American Elected by the People Were Excluded from Office Robert M. Lichtman provides a definitive history of congressional exclusion and expulsion cases. Lichtman offers a timely investigation of the vital constitutional issues, debated since the nation’s founding, concerning permissible and impermissible grounds for excluding a member-elect or expelling a member from Congress. Barred by Congress begins with an exhaustive review of the numerous congressional exclusion and expulsion cases in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries before focusing on the stories of the last three members-elect to be excluded from Congress: a Mormon, a Socialist, and an African American—each an outsider in American politics—excluded notwithstanding election by the voters. Lichtman illuminates each of these three remarkable individuals with a detailed biographical sketch. Brigham H. Roberts was a Utah Mormon whose exclusion from the House of Representatives in 1900 was fueled by a nationwide anti-Mormon campaign waged by William Randolph Hearst and his newspaper empire, a controversy centered on the issue of polygamy. Victor L. Berger, a Socialist Party leader and editor of an antiwar Milwaukee newspaper during World War I, was elected to the House despite the efforts of the Wilson administration to derail his campaign by indicting him under the Espionage Act; he was excluded in 1919 and again in 1920. Adam Clayton Powell Jr. was a Baptist minister and civil rights advocate who represented the Harlem neighborhood of New York City in the House of Representatives from 1945 until his exclusion in 1967. In Powell v. McCormack, the Supreme Court ruled that Powell’s exclusion by the House violated the Constitution, a decision that, a half century later, remains established law but still does not provide complete assurance that the people will be able to (in Alexander Hamilton’s words) “choose whom they please to govern them.”

Publisher

University Press of Kansas

Published

2022-01-27

Pages

384

Language

EN

Political Science / American Government / Legislative Branch

Preview & Source

Google Books provider

Preview bookView on Google BooksFind similar booksExplore category

Preview

Barred by Congress cover

This book is available for preview through Google Books.

More by Robert M. Lichtman

The Supreme Court and McCarthy-Era Repression cover
History2012-08-15

The Supreme Court and McCarthy-Era Repression

One Hundred Decisions

Robert M. Lichtman

In this volume, attorney Robert M. Lichtman provides a comprehensive history of the U.S. Supreme Court's decisions in "Communist" cases during the McCarthy era. Lichtman shows the Court's vulnerability to public criticism and attacks by the elected branches during periods of political repression. The book describes every Communist-related decision of the era (none is omitted), placing them in the context of political events and revealing the range and intrusiveness of McCarthy-era repression. In Fred Vinson's term as chief justice (1946-53), the Court largely rubber-stamped government action against accused Communists and "subversives." After Earl Warren replaced Vinson as chief justice in 1953, however, the Court began to rule against the government in "Communist" cases, choosing the narrowest of grounds but nonetheless outraging public opinion and provoking fierce attacks from the press and Congress. Legislation to curb the Court flooded Congress and seemed certain to be enacted. The Court's situation was aggravated by its 1954 school-desegregation decision, Brown v. Board of Education, which led to an anti-Court alliance between southern Democrats and anti-Communists in both parties. Although Lyndon Johnson's remarkable talents as Senate majority leader saved the Court from highly punitive legislation, the attacks caused the Court to retreat, with Felix Frankfurter leading a five-justice majority that decided major constitutional issues for the government and effectively nullified earlier decisions. Only after August 1962, when Frankfurter retired and was replaced by Arthur Goldberg, did the Court again begin to vindicate individual rights in "Communist" cases--its McCarthy era was over. Demonstrating keen insight into the Supreme Court's inner workings and making extensive use of the justices' papers, Lichtman examines the dynamics of the Court's changes in direction and the relationships and rivalries among its justices, including such towering figures as Hugo Black, Felix Frankfurter, Earl Warren, William O. Douglas, and William J. Brennan, Jr. The Supreme Court and McCarthy-Era Repression: One Hundred Decisions tells the entire story of the Supreme Court during this unfortunate period of twentieth-century American history.

Barred by CongressRobert M. Lichtman
African American legislators2021

Barred by Congress

How a Mormon, a Socialist, and an African American Elected by the People Were Excluded from Office

Robert M. Lichtman

"On March 2, 1967, the New York Times ran the extra-large headline: "HOUSE EXCLUDES POWELL." The sensational story about Congress's exclusion of the long-term African American House member, Adam Clayton Powell, Jr., led to a legal battle over the constitutionality of excluding a representative who had been duly elected by the people and met the constitutional requirements for office. Those who supported the exclusion cited the two most recent examples, namely, the exclusion in 1900 of Brigham H. Roberts, a polygamist Mormon elected in Utah, and the double exclusion in 1919 and 1920 of Victor L. Berger, a socialist newspaper editor elected in Wisconsin. All three of these controversial figures were political outsiders, and all three exclusions involved objectionable motives: religious bias (Roberts), political bias (Berger), and racial bias (Powell). Robert Lichtman has written the definitive work on exclusions and expulsions from Congress. In addition to providing biographies of three remarkable figures in American history, this work illuminates an often ignored or misunderstood aspect of congressional politics, which culminated in the landmark Supreme Court case, Powell v. McCormack. Denying the Most Unbounded Liberty-referring to Alexander Hamilton's claim in the Federalist Papers that the people's ability to choose their representatives is "the most unbounded liberty allowed"-tells the story of these three attempts to deny this liberty, what Hamilton calls "the true principle of a republic.""--

Deadly Farce cover
Biography & Autobiography2004

Deadly Farce

Harvey Matusow and the Informer System in the McCarthy Era

Robert M. Lichtman, Ronald D. Cohen

Robert M. Lichtman and Ronald D. Cohen draw on FBI records, court transcripts, personal interviews, private papers, and other primary sources, most never before utilized, to describe the unusual role of ex-Communist informer-witnesses during the McCarthy era. The Justice Department kept several dozen ex-Communist political informers on the government's payroll to testify in hundreds of deportation, sedition, and contempt of Congress cases. Some informers achieved celebrity as the result of high-profile appearances at criminal trials and before Congressional committees. But as the era continued, instances of perjury began to appear. Harvey Matusow's sensational recantation in 1955 gave him his biggest audience yet. It also led to dissolution of the Justice Department's informer stable and ended the public's infatuation with the group.

More in Political Science / American Government / Legislative Branch

Repealing National Prohibition cover
History2000

Repealing National Prohibition

Honorée Fanonne Jeffers, David E. Kyvig

A study of the political reaction against the 18th Amendment, a response that led to its reversal 14 years later by the 21st Amendment. This work uses archival evidence to examine the liquor ban and to draw attention to the bi-partisan movement led by the Association Against Prohibition Amendment.

The Education of a Senator cover
Biography & Autobiography1998

The Education of a Senator

Everett McKinley Dirksen

Recently discovered in the archives of the Dirksen Congressional Center, this is the memoir Senator Dirksen was writing at the time of this death in 1969. Covering the years of his boyhood through his election to the senate in 1950, it reveals the foundation of a great public servant in the making. His gravel-voiced warmth and wisdom come through on every page.

Parties and Leaders in the Postreform House cover
History1991-08-13

Parties and Leaders in the Postreform House

David W. Rohde

Since the Second World War, congressional parties have been characterized as declining in strength and influence. Research has generally attributed this decline to policy conflicts within parties, to growing electoral independence of members, and to the impact of the congressional reforms of the 1970s. Yet the 1980s witnessed a strong resurgence of parties and party leadership—especially in the House of Representatives. Offering a concise and compelling explanation of the causes of this resurgence, David W. Rohde argues that a realignment of electoral forces led to a reduction of sectional divisions within the parties—particularly between the northern and southern Democrats—and to increased divergence between the parties on many important issues. He challenges previous findings by asserting that congressional reform contributed to, rather than restrained, the increase of partisanship. Among the Democrats, reforms siphoned power away from conservative and autocratic committee chairs and put control of those committees in the hands of Democratic committee caucuses, strengthening party leaders and making both party and committee leaders responsible to rank-and-file Democrats. Electoral changes increased the homogeneity of House Democrats while institutional reforms reduced the influence of dissident members on a consensus in the majority party. Rohde's accessible analysis provides a detailed discussion of the goals of the congressional reformers, the increased consensus among Democrats and its reinforcement by their caucus, the Democratic leadership's use of expanded powers to shape the legislative agenda, and the responses of House Republicans. He also addresses the changes in the relationship between the House majority and the president during the Carter and Reagan administrations and analyzes the legislative consequences of the partisan resurgence. A readable, systematic synthesis of the many complex factors that fueled the recent resurgence of partisanship, Parties and Leaders in the Postreform House is ideal for course use.

Congressional Dynamics cover
Political Science1994

Congressional Dynamics

Structure, Coordination, and Choice in the First American Congress, 1774-1789

Calvin C. Jillson, Rick K. Wilson

This book focuses on the origins, evolution, and demise of the Continental Congress, reinterpreting its successes and failures from the perspective of the ?new institutionalism.” In the process, the book lays open a fascinating historical laboratory for exploring contemporary questions about the nature of political institutions, the strategic incentives those institutions present to those involved, and the outcomes that result.

Stalin's Holy War cover
History2003

Stalin's Holy War

Religion, Nationalism, and Alliance Politics, 1941-1945

Steven Merritt Miner

This volume examines the complex and profound role of religion, especially Russian Orthodoxy, in the politics of Stalin's government during World War II. It demonstrates that Stalin decided to restore the church to prominence as a tool for restoring Soviet power to previously occupied areas.

Similar books

The Autobiography of B. H. Roberts cover
Biography & Autobiography1990

The Autobiography of B. H. Roberts

Brigham Henry Roberts

His storybook adventures made him a household name during his lifetime. His impassioned speeches incited civil disturbances, his reasoned writings defined and codified religious beliefs, and his candid disclosures of Utah history brought him both respect and censure.

Congressional Record cover
Law1962

Congressional Record

Proceedings and Debates of the ... Congress

United States. Congress

Description unavailable for this volume in the current provider response.

War on the American Republic cover
Political Science2024-10-15

War on the American Republic

How Liberalism Became Despotism

Kevin Slack

Kevin Slack sounds the alarm on how America's failed neoliberal regime has given way to a woke oligarchy that has deployed a radical toolkit to rapidly strip away the rights of citizens. Americans often use the words progressive, liberal, and radical more or less interchangeably without understanding their place in American history. Kevin Slack describes the distinct aims of the movements they represent and weighs their consequences for the American republic. Each of the three movements rejected older republican principles of governance in favor of an administrative state, but there were substantial differences between Teddy Roosevelt’s Anglo-Protestant progressive social gospelers, who battled trusts and curbed immigration; Franklin Roosevelt’s and Lyndon Johnson’s secular liberals, who forged a government-business partnership and promoted a civil rights agenda; and the 1960s radicals, who protested corporate influence in the Great Society, liberal hypocrisy on race and gender, and the war in Vietnam. Each sought to overturn what came before. Following the revolution of the 1960s, elites on both left and right turned against the industrial middle class to erect an oligarchy at home and advance globalization abroad. Each side claimed to serve the interests of disadvantaged or underrepresented groups. Radicals ensconced themselves in bureaucracy and academia to advance their vision of social justice for women and minorities, while neoliberal elites promoted monopoly finance, open borders, and the outsourcing of jobs to benefit consumers. The administrative state became a global American empire, but the neoliberals’ economic and military failures precipitated a crisis of legitimacy. In the “great awokening” that began under Barack Obama, neoliberal elites, including establishment conservatives, openly broke with the populist base of the Republican Party, embraced identity politics, and used COVID-19 and a myth of insurrection to strip away the rights of American citizens. Today, an incompetent kleptocracy is draining the wealthiest and most powerful people in history, thus eroding the foundations of its own empire.

The Wobblies in Their Heyday cover
History2014-08-26

The Wobblies in Their Heyday

The Rise and Destruction of the Industrial Workers of the World during the World War I Era

Eric Thomas Chester

During World War I, the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) rose to prominence as an effective, militant union and then was destroyed by a devastating campaign of repression launched by the federal government. This book documents the rise and fall of this important industrial labor organization. The Industrial Workers of the World—or "Wobblies," as they were known—included legendary figures from U.S. labor history. Joe Hill, "Big Bill" Haywood, and Elizabeth Gurley Flynn have become a part of American popular folklore. In this book, author Eric T. Chester shows just how dynamic a force the IWW was during its heyday during World War I, and how determined the federal government was to crush this union—a campaign of repression that remains unique in U.S. history. This work utilizes a wide array of archival sources, many of them never used before, thereby giving readers a clearer view and better understanding of what actually happened. The book leads with an examination of the three key events in the history of the IWW: the Wheatfield, CA, confrontation; the Bisbee, AZ, deportation; and the strike of copper miners in Butte, MT. The second part of the book deconstructs the IWW's responses to World War I, the coordinated attack by the federal government upon the union, and how the union unraveled under this attack.

Symposium cover
Law1967

Symposium

The Philosophy of H.L.A. Hart

Unknown author

Description unavailable for this volume in the current provider response.

Book details

Publisher: University Press of Kansas

Published: 2022-01-27

Pages: 384

Language: EN

Categories: Political Science / American Government / Legislative Branch

Preview: Sample available

PDF: Available

Ventari Books links to external provider metadata and access states and does not rehost copyrighted text.

We use optional analytics and advertising cookies to understand how visitors use Ventari, measure ads, and improve the experience. You can accept all optional cookies, allow analytics only, or decline them. See our Cookie Policy.