mcp—August 11, 2023✓ Verified purchase
I have trich, and I have needed to wear eyeliner every day to cover it up for years. This is the best one I have found for that. It is cheap, so I am not breaking the bank with the amount of eyeliner I need to buy. It is VERY pigmented and does not irritate my eyes. And, it usually lasts throughout the entire day with minimal wear, even on my hooded eyelids. I only occasionally need to touch it up on particularly long days or after a nap. I have worn this in the pool even and it lasted. It is kind of difficult to remove all the way manually, but after a shower and sleep I usually wake with it completely gone and it's never caused a problem. It can also clump, and the soft tip needs sharpening often. It can be hard sometimes to apply just a thin line, but I have managed it with practice and if I do put too much, I quickly swipe my finger just under my eyeliner to thin it out before it sets. But overall, it is by far the best eyeliner I have found for what I need it for. Read more
Melissa Beddingfield—November 28, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I was pleasantly surprised at how the eyeliner looked when applied. It stayed on all day. It was a good price! I love that Cover Girl doesn’t test on animals anymore. Read more
amber—September 16, 2025✓ Verified purchase
It goes on smoothly. The color is very nice. It goes on thick so you have to is lightly. Definitely stays on, even after swimming, does not smudge. Great value for the money. Read more
Mary butler—January 3, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Blackest black eyeliner I’ve tried Read more
Customer—July 12, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Why did you pick this product vs others?: Best ever eyeliner for waterline. Doesn't budge all day. Lovelove love this. My only ask is to please make it a twist able, sharpening is such a chore ! And takes a lot of the product away. Read more
Acorn—January 11, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Nearly impossible to sharpen. Liked it for 3 to 4 uses. Tried sharpening and its a hard plastic like material. I have a sharpener for eye pencils but.... wow. Why??? Read more
🌷Whattajewell🌷—August 17, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Ok,,,,,, Don't buy this because I want all of it!!THIS is the shade I've been searching for! It is perfect for green eyes! It just makes them look amazing! Easy to use and stays on all day! Read more
Nana—October 31, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This product is a waste of time and money. There is very little eyeliner in the pencil so it lasts about 7-10 days. You can turn the end but no additional eyeliner comes up. I bought this eyeliner twice - thinking it was my fault - but had the same problem. Don't waste your time. Read more
