MAYBELLINE Sculpting Stix 2-in-1 Eyeliner Dual Ended Brown Eye Liner With Up to 24HR Wear Smudge and Sweat-Resistant

I love the shape of this liner! It's incredibly tiny, which is appreciated, but I also like the angle and the fact that it stays that way. Stays on pretty well with my watery outer corners, yet oily lids. I might have a little smudging on the outer corner when I've had my makeup on for 10+ hrs, but overall it stays put. The tiny brush in the other end is great as well, I often use it for powdered eyeliner too and it's absolutely perfect for hooded lids like mine. It's the eyeliner brush I've been looking for and couldn't find! Brown is the perfect shade- not too light or too dark. Read more

I really like how fine the tip is on this eyeliner. It glides on smoothly and lasts all day for me under optimal circumstances. It doesn't seem to hold up to a heavy sweat or the rain though. I do have to make sure I use a light touch because it broke off pretty easily the first few times I used jt. Overall though I really like it. Read more

The easiest way to get into your lash line! This eyeliner is perfectly shaped, pigmented & creamy that you can get right down into your lash line & create a soft wing by flicking it out w/ a thin brush or smudging it for a more smoky/grungy effect. My mom snatched it from me because the application was so much easier for her arthritic hands due to its precise shape and creamy formulation. Anyway, 5/5, Highly recommend! Read more

I'm trying to shift from a black liquid liner to a softer brown pencil as I age (46) and this has been a nice option to start with. I love a wing, and the brush gives me the ability to add a small wing when lining. Read more

The easiest smokey wing liner in seconds!! So buttery and glides easily and the brush is small but precise, I love it. Read more

This review is for the color "Hazy Taupe." This eyeliner is very smooth and creamy and holds up incredibly well. When I tested it on my hand, washing my hands didn't alter it at all and I could not scrub it off even with a baby wipe - the only thing that removed it was an oil based makeup remover. So it will definitely stay where you put it, which I love! The color is a little warmer than I expected for taupe, but it is still a nice color and overall is more cool than warm. I didn't love the angled applicator and would prefer a traditional pencil tip. The angled applicator means you have to hold the pencil a certain way for it to go on right, and the tip breaks off more easily because the angle makes it easier to accidentally shear off certain parts if you don't have it perfectly flush against your skin. You do get a pretty good amount of product, I spun the pencil all the way out and there is around 1.5" of product total, so I think that's pretty reasonable for $10. Overall I think I'll stick to my existing favorite liner because of the minor drawbacks I outlined, but this is a solid alternative for me and I love how well it stays put. Read more

Nothing special. Not friendly to mature lids. Formula is stiff and dry and skips more than a CD in a monster truck. Dry formula makes the brush end useless. This isn't creamy enough to smudge. I'll just use that end as a shadow brush.. for brown eyeshadow.. that I already have. That will be more useful for me than the eyeliner end. Womp womp. Read more

This is the perfect liner, and the brush actually works unlike many products with a smudger/brush that just wipe the liner off. Read more