CS—January 30, 2026✓ Verified purchase
My mistake! I noticed the bit of sparkle in the listing photos, but I just didn't imagine this pencil would be so GLITTERY. It does glide on smoothly and cleanly. It's easy to control and it certainly stays put. In fact, it stays put so well that there's really no chance to blend or soften it. So you get a clean, hard line with a lot of sparkle in it. Not at all appropriate for a lady my age, but my grandniece loves it. She hopes there's a glittery black one, too. Read more
vcobo—August 7, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I have used this product for over 10 years now, I have purchase other eyeliners, but I always go back to this one, it is the perfect tone of brown for my complexion, the shiny finish gives it a special something, it gives you time to work it, but you will lose the shiny finish; once it is set, there is no going back, it does not move, long wearing and smudge proof. Read more
SeSe62—July 10, 2021✓ Verified purchase
For years I've been using a very expensive eyeliner. I have sensitive eyes and have to be careful about the eye products I use. I also prefer waterproof eyeliner and mascara because my eyes tend to water a lot. I was tired of paying the high price for the expensive eyeliner and thought I would give this a try for a very decent and low price. I was in for a very nice surprise. It worked perfectly, the color stayed in place and lasted for hours. The color did not smudge or smear, but I want to make a note that I am not a professional workout person nor do I do marathon runs. But I wanted something that I could put on in the morning and go into the office and not worrying about checking my makeup every 15 minutes. You will need to buy a pencil sharpener for it but those are relatively inexpensive. I've seen comments about that, but I bought a pencil sharpener from Elf and absolutely had no problems sharpening it back up. I use Neutrogena makeup remover wipes at night and it takes it right off. The best thing about this product for me, is that it did not cause any eye sensitivity or tearing. I also really love the color and it seems to have just a tiny touch of a shimmer to it that really makes your eyes pop without looking like you're going to the club. For the price, you can guarantee that the old very expensive eyeliner is no longer going to be used. Read more
Pamela Halton—November 3, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I've used a lot of liner pencils but this is the fifth one I buy of this brand. It goes on easy, doesn't smudge and this color is perfect with my green eyes and blonde hair. It also stays on all night untill I take it off. Read more
Joann culver—February 1, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Absolutely amazing liner!! Does not smudge after 1 minute of drying time!! Love the color! I wish I could get more colors for this price. Read more
Loverofgoodbooks—September 24, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Best color ever for my grey blue eyes. Goes on smooth, stays on all day. Great quality! No eye irritation, it goes on quickly and dries fast too. I like to smudge mine a bit to blend it. Read more
TRUSTED CONSUMER—September 25, 2025✓ Verified purchase
The brown is rich and vibrant. Seems to have a hint of sparkle and I would consider it more of a bronze. I can’t remark yet whether it is actually waterproof. **It will require a sharpener that is specific for a gel.** Even with that , the point is not very precise. It glides very well. But because of that, is soft and breaks, wasting product causing it to need to be sharpened at each use. It would be absolutely ideal if it were the same product in a retractable crayon. This would make it unquestionably 5 star. Because this is the case, you will likely go through much more product, making it comparable to a more expensive crayon. Read more
BlueRidge—January 16, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Applies so smooth and easy !! I like it! Read more