Jeremey Griffith—January 11, 2026✓ Verified purchase
This is my absolute favorite eyeliner! I have used this eyeliner since I was in 5th grade! They changed the formula like 5 years ago and it isn't as good as it used to be. But I found the grass isn't that much greener and that it still is one of the best options out there even if it isn't as good as it used to be. It goes on your water line so thick and smooth, especially if you run it through a flame or heat it up a little bit. It is waterproof and it does stay on for 24+ hours! You might have to reapply to your waterline but I think thats just cause it's your waterline, and not the fault of the eyeliner. It sharpens nicely and the smudger on the end is an amazing tool that you should use wherever you apply the eyeliner. It helps set it in a way and makes it even as well as smudges it in so that you don't have just a thick line. The price is decent and it arrives super fast. Read more
Customer—February 13, 2026✓ Verified purchase
My favorite eye liner pencil. It goes on smoothly and looks natural. Read more
Cristen Merillat—January 2, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Have used this eyeliner for years. I’ve tried other brands and colors, but keep going back to this one. The application is easy and the thickness of the pencil doesn’t irritate my eyes. The color is a dark black, which I haven’t found in other brands. Even applying it daily, a pencil lasts me quite a long time. Read more
Alyn—February 12, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Great everyday eyeliner. It glides on smoothly and the blending tip makes it easy to soften the line. Good pigmentation without being too harsh. It does need a little touch-up after several hours, but for the price, it performs really well. Solid drugstore staple Read more
STORMY—February 12, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I have been using this eye pencil for years and it’s my favorite. The color is spot on. It doesn’t run or smudge. Nice sharp lines. Stays on all day. I do not like the newer liquid pencils. Read more
Mary Lynne—February 12, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Have used this product for long time. Will reorder again. Read more
L Nielson—January 31, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Lovely shade, but it’s too hard and almost impossible to apply. Read more
Super cute and comfy.i love that they are more a fitted sweatpants than loose and baggy—February 1, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Use this as a teenager. I've tried so many eyeliners , and I finally going back to cover girl. It's a great price & great eyeliner. Glides on smooth and lasts. Read more
