Skarlet espitia—December 15, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This e.l.f. eyeliner is super easy to apply and very precise. The tip glides smoothly without tugging, making it perfect for both thin lines and winged looks. It dries quickly and lasts all day without smudging. Great quality for the price and perfect for everyday use. Read more
ALLISON.C—October 16, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Love it. Use it almost everyday only issue is if you do bigger eyeliner the ink will run out quicker along with how the black slowly loses its color. Never has it irritated my eye thing. It is pretty easy to put on because of the felt tip but over time it does start to wear out. Quality is pretty good the spring in the lid is a bit hard to open if you dont put it back on right. Read more
Barbara Pardue—February 4, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I have used this product for a while. Came quick, sharp point, dry's quick, great color, and lasts long! Read more
Eti—February 4, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Not the worst eyeliner I've tried, it works pretty well and has pretty good payoff. I have to layer over it twice sometimes, but I do have oily skin so that's a big factor as a lot of eyeliners do that for me. It does come off easier than others I've tried, I have watery eyes and this does not last against it, but it's not sticky and dries fast. My biggest gripe is the felt tip is very stiff, like very. It made it hard to use at first but it's actually perfect for inner corner eyeliner! Read more
Eric—January 28, 2026✓ Verified purchase
This eyeliner is so underrated. Its affordable and really easy to use. I used to buy eyeliner are the $30 price point but when I decided to cut down my budget I switched to this and was amazed that I liked it even better than all the other more expensive ones I had tried. Read more
Jess So—October 20, 2025✓ Verified purchase
beautiful for the first week-ish but after that, quickly "waters itself down" i.e. if you get too much oil or product on the tip, it ruins the pigment payoff forever and might even make the tip dry up. i still use it to sketch out my eyeliner but i'm a little frustrated with the longevity of the felt tip. Read more
Sarah—January 19, 2026✓ Verified purchase
i love this eyeliner so much it's perfect for any style and as a scene kid, i use it all the time and it doesn't dry out very fast Read more
carmel rutman—December 10, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I have been using this Elf Eyeliner pen for years... never any issues. This time I purchased from Amazon... horrible. All watery. Will not buy again from Amazon. Read more